drogheda wrote:Maybe it would be more accurate if in Gsow ranking league will be based on not CBS but CBS per member of squad
If I follow what has been suggested so far, combined base score (CBS) as proposed will be based on the total squad at time of ranking. What is being suggested now is CBS should be based on the war squad members in order to be more accurate. I believe that the suggestion would bring more volatility to the ranking process and would also be susceptible to manipulation along the lines of the war squad would be only high base score members to gain a higher ranking. Of course the ranking would change as the war squad lineup changes. Same could be said of the proposed method. So I guess the real question is how accurate does it have to be? Given the current state of squad wars where some players are now willing to war in other squads in order to fill rosters, the ranking would only apply to that squad on that given data poll. As soon as the war is over and players move on to allow others to fill for the next war, the CBS changes accordingly. If the players that join the roster all have similar base scores compared to those that left, no big deal. If not, then the ranking changes on the next data poll. A squad with a consistent roster would have no problem placing within their league standing. Those that host a roster from heavy hitters to beginner bases will fluctuate amongst the leagues accordingly. So again, how much accuracy is needed with those given variables?