I have attacked players in the past and only got a 1 star but log shows 100%. Equally similar odd results when players attack me.
The game is buggy and replay is not a video replay. Disney always say that log is correct, not the replay.
I never notice the name of the players I attack, or the ones who attack me. It is not important.
So best just get on with the game.
Active Imperial war squads : Spawn and Spawn~Rising.
(Spawn for level 8 or above) join us for back to back wars
(Spawn~Rising for any level) join us